Old Georgetown Appendix: CFA Meeting — 21 September 2004

No objection to concept design for proposed partial demolition of rear addition, new rear addition, separate residential building on rear yard, replacement windows on lower level of front facade and alterations to the front cornice, as shown in Option 1 of supplemental drawings received and dated 25 August 2004 which indicate 5 windows on West facade. File new submission of working drawings, including dimensions, details and material samples, with permit application for review by the Commission when ready. Signs were not part of this concept submission.

No objection to issuance of permit for existing fixed tables and chairs on public space for sidewalk cafe at Thomas Sweet Ice Cream PROVIDED existing railing, which is out-of-character, not necessary since the tables are fixed and was NOT approved, is removed. Proposed wood platforms for tables were NOT approved.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed relocation of existing entry door to the front of vestibule.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations to multi-family residential building, including repair of existing windows, alterations to openings on rear facade with new wood windows to match existing, vertical wood board fence and gate to be painted or stained, and excavation of courtyard at basement level to project into public space no further than stoop of adjacent building as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 14 September 2004. Recommend AGAINST issuance of permit for proposed roof decks and roof access which, as noted on site visit on 21 September 2004, will be visible from public space and not appropriate to the historic district. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed repair of cast iron front stoop, including disassembling, reconstruction with replacement only of missing parts to match existing, and re-installation in its original placement and configuration.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed repair of cast iron front stoop, including disassembling, reconstruction with replacement only of missing parts to match existing, and re-installation in its original placement and configuration.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed revisions to approved design for existing stone-clad fireplace / exhaust chimney as shown in drawings received and dated 19 August 2004 which indicate as-built conditions. No objection to lighting plan as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 19 August 2004. Recommend AGAINST issuance of permit for revisions to introduce a 16-inch high stone wall, 7'-0" tall steel fence and metal stairs at end of driveway / planter which deviates from approved design and would negatively impact the openness of the alley (an integral part of the approved design). See previous Recommendations (OG 04-176 and OG 02-301). After a site visit, the Commission notes that portion of the fence has already been installed behind driveway and must be removed no later than 31 December 2004. Note is made that design details for proposed new fence deviates from approved design of existing fences. The Commission regrets that so many parts of the project, including the stone chimney and the lighting fixtures, have been completed without review or permit and requests that approved landscaping atop wall and grading of landscaped berm at base of retaining wall along 32nd Street be installed as agreed. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations and repair of the ticket booth at Dumbarton Oaks, including replacement of roof to match existing, new windows, and mechanical equipment where it won't be visible from public space.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed projecting sign reading 'Urban Chic' on existing bracket to be painted silver and relocated to meet code requirements, as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 23 August 2004.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed replacement of stockade fence with a 6'-0' high vertical board fence with gothic tips as shown in either of the options on supplemental drawings. Fence must be painted or stained.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations to front yard on public space for a landscaped bed, including new window wells, brick planter wall no taller than 19-inches and brick pavers at entrance.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit on 23 August 2004 indicate that proposed deck and trellis at first floor level at rear will not be visible from public space. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the proposed design as a result of further review in the permit process that would make the work visible must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations, including excavation of rear yard for basement court and new stairs to covered door, for new brick garden wall and gate; and for repair of existing windows, brick walls and architectural detailing. Working drawings conform to approved concept. See previous Recommendation (OG 04-215). Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations for the Georgetown University Mortara Center, including alterations to window openings, new bay windows and door surround on historic building, new landscaped planting beds with low loop iron fence, and relocation and reduction in size of mechanical equipment on roof. Electrical meter will remain in existing location inside the building. Working drawings, which indicate clear differentiation between historic and 20th century buildings, conform to approved concept. See previous Recommendation (OG 04-154). Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for only two of the proposed 8' x 2' fabric banners at 2nd floor level at either side of entrance facing the Georgetown Market with signs reading 'Washington Sports Club' as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 2 September 2004. Additional banners, including the one proposed for M Street, were NOT approved and have been deleted from this permit application. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for already completed removal of aluminum siding, and for repair of existing wood Dutch siding, which should be retained with replacement to match existing ONLY when necessary. Recommend removal of aluminum box to expose original cornice and screening of electric meter. Commission regrets that work was initiated prior to review and permit. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to general concept design for proposed addition of third floor behind a sloped roof as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 20 August 2004. Recommend further study of new window openings at rear. File new submission of working drawings, including dimensions and details, with permit application for review by the Commission when ready.

Recommend AGAINST issuance of permit for fence and gates as proposed. Request submission of comprehensive plan for treatment of retaining wall, grading, landscaping and revised design for fence with piers and lattice top to match existing fence elsewhere on property. File new submission of working drawings, including dimensions, details and grading plan with permit application for review by the Commission when ready. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review which must be resolved prior to new submission.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed rear deck, wood vertical board fence with lattice top and gates to be no taller than 7'-0" high, and a pergola no taller than 8'-0" high, as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 2 September 2004. Fence and gates to be painted or stained.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit on 23 August 2004 indicate that alterations to masonry openings at side yard terrace will not be visible from public space. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed 4-story rear addition with either option of materials selection as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 2 September 2004. Working drawings conform to approved concept. See previous Recommendation (OG 04-149). Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval. Erect a sample panel of the final materials selection for review by the Commission prior to ordering materials.

Recommend AGAINST issuance of permit for proposed rear addition and trellis. Although there is no objection to general concept of a trellis in this location, submitted materials are insufficient for permit review. Requested supplemental drawings were not submitted on a timely manner. File new submission of working drawings, including dimensions, construction details, accurate site plan and floor plans, with permit application for review by the Commission when ready. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review which should be resolved prior to new submission.

No objection to concept design for proposed re-setting of bricks on sidewalk and for new 12-inch high fence in tree beds on public space. No objection to issuance of permit for proposed repointing of brick mortar joints to be coordinated with the Historic Preservation Review Board. File new submission of fence details with a public space permit application for review by the Commission when ready.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials are insufficient for permit review. Request submission of new application with additional working detailed drawings on grade, fence, retaining wall and paving materials. Note is made that permit application is pending final zoning review which must be resolved prior to new submission. Commission questions information on application pertinent to property ownership.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed fabric awning with lettering reading 'Grace and Bamboo' on 12-inch high valance, for non-illuminated 7'-10" x 1'-6" projecting sign, for two new light fixtures as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 25 August 2004. No objection to general concept of replacement of windows at first floor level along west facade, which have been replaced and are in disrepair, with all wood or aluminum-clad wood windows. All other windows to be repaired and repainted. No objection to the removal of nailed-on shutters which should not be re-installed. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit must be submitted to the Commission for approval. File separate submission of detailed information on replacement windows with permit application for review by the Commission when ready.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed mural by Artifice of either three flowers, which is the preferred option, or two flowers, which received previous concept approval (OG 04-147) on wall facing onto parking lot and M Street as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 24 August 2004. No lettering should be part of the mural, except for the artist's signature. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for existing alterations to the rear wing, including wood replacement windows and alterations to door surround, for trellis over rear patio, brick garden wall, parking area off alley, and for wood siding and enlarged window opening on third floor PROVIDED the doors in this opening are not-operable. Commission regrets that work was completed prior to review and without a permit. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations to front court, including removal of existing concrete floor, new brick-paved bridge to entry door, repair of existing wood windows, and two metal planters as shown in Option A of supplemental drawings received and dated 23 August 2004. Working drawings conform to approved concept. See previous Recommendation (OG 04-219). Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit on 23 August 2004 indicate that alterations to lower level masonry openings at rear will not be visible from public space. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board. Applicant deleted removal of shutters from this application. Shutters will be retained. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the proposed design as a result of further review in the permit process that would make the work visible must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed addition of dormers and replacement of roof shingles with slate, PROVIDED previously built dormer is corrected to match approved design, with the required repair of brick wall. See previous Recommendation (OG 98-210). Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the proposed design as a result of further review in the permit process that would make the work visible must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to concept design for proposed alterations to brick stoop for new storage area. Recommend use of a solid wood gate painted dark green or black. File new submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for review by the Commission when ready.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed alterations to carriage house, including partial demolition, re-construction of upper floor and new garage off alley, as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 9 September 2004. Overhead garage door has been deleted from this application and will be submitted separately. Working drawings conform to approved concept. See previous recommendation (OG 04-178). Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed swimming pool on garden terrace as revised and for existing construction entrance on 29th Street gate which will be re-constructed in brick and stucco to match original detailing as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 17 August and 25 August 2004. Commission regrets that partial demolition of gate and wall took place prior to review and without a permit. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to general concept for proposed new masonry openings for basement windows. Recommend further study of placement and number of windows on side wall, as well as detailing of size and configuration of front windows, including arch heads and relationship to existing stoop. File separate submission of working drawings, including dimensions and details, with permit application for review by the Commission when ready.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit on 23 August 2004 indicate that one-story structure on rear yard is not visible from public space. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board.

No objection to issuance of permit for revisions to approved design for alterations to storefront on Cady's Alley as shown in drawings received and dated 13 August 2004 which indicate retention of existing masonry openings along alley. Sign was NOT part of this application as name is yet to be determined. See previous cases (OG 04-151 and OG 04-98). File separate submission of working drawings, including details and dimensions, with permit application for sign for review by the Commission when ready. Note is made that permit application is pending final zoning review. Any modifications to the approved design as a result of further review in the permit process must be submitted to the Commission for approval.

No objection to concept design for proposed single garage door that will replicate previous conditions during the Kennedy residency, for proposed repairs and replacement of wood railing with metal railing at roof deck. See previous Recommendations (OG 04-186). File new submission of working drawings, including dimensions and details, with detailed plans for restoration of stone wall showing extent of demolition, after exploratory study of wall stability, with permit application for review by the Commission prior to any excavation work behind the wall.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit on 23 August 2004 indicate that alterations to the parapet and to the lower level masonry openings at rear will not be visible from public space. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board. Note is made that permit application is pending final Zoning review.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed sign composed of back-lit 10-inch high letters reading 'Hershey's' pin-mounted to the storefront as shown in supplemental drawings received and dated 18 August 2004.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed reconstruction of pier and brick retaining wall, which failed structurally, using salvaged brick and new brick to match existing. Erect a brick sample panel for review by the Commission prior to installation. No objection to repair of metal gates. File separate submission of working drawings with permit application for proposed repair/replacement of driveway for review by the Commission when ready.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed replacement of stockade fence with 6'-high Wyngate style wood fence on rear yard. Fence must be stained or painted.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit of 23 August 2004 indicate that two existing new windows in place of previously existing door openings, and a new window on rear facade are not visible from public space. Commission regrets that work was completed without a permit. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board. Note is made that previously existing two-story side porch was removed without review or permit and must be reconstructed. File separate submission of working drawings, including dimensions and details, with permit application for side porch for review by the Commission when ready.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed single garage door that will replicate previous conditions during the Kennedy residency, for proposed repairs and for replacement of wood railing with metal railing at roof deck. Approval does not include reconstruction of stone wall, as further study is needed to determine extent and approach of repair work. Working drawings conform to approved concept. See previous Recommendation (OG 04-264). File separate submission of detailed plans for restoration of stone wall indicating extent of demolition, after exploratory study of wall stability, with permit application for review by the Commission prior to any excavation work behind the wall.

No objection to issuance of permit for proposed replacement of stockade fence with a 6-ft high board and batten wood fence on rear yard. New fence must be stained or painted.

Returned without Action. Submitted materials and a site visit of 21 September 2004 indicate that proposed wire trellis above existing rear yard fence will not be visible from public space. Refer to the Historic Preservation Review Board.